Not every card needs the same amount of clearance inside a toploader, and forcing a thick memorabilia card into a standard-thickness holder is a fast way to crack the plastic or bend the card itself. Thickness is measured in points, and getting that number wrong is one of the more common toploader mistakes collectors make.
The EVORETRO 130pt Heavy-Duty Toploader is built specifically for thick memorabilia and patch cards that standard toploaders cannot comfortably fit. The EVORETRO Multi-Thickness Toploader Pack covers the more common range collectors actually need day to day.
Here is how to tell which thickness a given card actually needs, and when paying for the specialty option is worth it versus when a standard toploader is the smarter, cheaper choice.
Toploader thickness is measured in points, referring to how much internal clearance the holder provides for the card sitting inside it. A 130pt toploader has meaningfully more depth than a standard 35pt or 55pt holder, built specifically to accommodate cards with extra material inside them.
That extra material usually comes from memorabilia swatches, thick foil stock, or multiple layers laminated into a single card. Standard toploaders simply were not designed with that added bulk in mind.
Memorabilia cards containing a jersey swatch, patch piece, or relic insert are the clearest case for a 130pt toploader. These cards are physically thicker than a standard card by design, and squeezing one into a thinner holder risks cracking the toploader or creasing the card itself, especially around the edges where the extra material sits closest to the plastic.
Thick parallel inserts and multi-layer die-cut cards fall into the same category. If a card visibly does not sit flush in a standard toploader, or the toploader will not close cleanly, that is a strong sign it needs the 130pt option instead, and forcing it shut anyway usually does more harm than good over time.
The vast majority of cards in any collection are standard thickness, and buying 130pt holders for regular base cards is an unnecessary expense. EVORETRO's multi-thickness pack covers a wide practical range at a lower per-card cost, which is the better choice for base cards, standard inserts, and most graded-adjacent raw cards.
Using a thicker toploader than a card actually needs also leaves extra room inside the holder, which can let the card shift and rub against the plastic during handling or shipping.
For memorabilia, patch, and thick insert cards, start with the EVORETRO 130pt Heavy-Duty Toploader Pack of 10, built with the extra clearance those cards actually need.
For everyday base cards and standard inserts, the EVORETRO Multi-Thickness Toploader Pack covers the common thickness range at a better per-card price for regular collection needs.
The 130pt pack of 10 runs $5.99, a fair price for a smaller pack built around a specific, less common need. The multi-thickness pack of 25 starts at $3.99 and covers a broader everyday range across more units, making it the more cost-efficient option for a typical collection.
Buying the specialty 130pt option only for the memorabilia cards that actually need it, and the standard multi-thickness pack for everything else, keeps overall toploader spending reasonable without compromising protection anywhere.
A quick visual and physical check is usually enough: hold the card up to a standard toploader and see if it sits flush without forcing the holder closed. If there is visible gapping or the toploader will not seal cleanly, that card likely needs the 130pt option instead, and it is worth setting those cards aside rather than guessing.
Sorting cards into thickness categories before ordering toploaders in bulk avoids ending up with the wrong mix, especially for collectors buying in bulk ahead of a show or a big sorting session. A short sorting pass up front usually saves a second order later once the wrong-thickness holders run out.
Memorabilia, patch, and thick multi-layer insert cards typically need the extra clearance of a 130pt toploader.
It covers the standard 35pt through 180pt range collectors commonly need for regular cards.
Per card, yes, since it is a smaller pack built for a more specific, less common need.
It is not recommended, since the card may not sit flush and the holder can crack or the card can bend.
Save the specialty holders for the cards that actually need them, and pick up the EVORETRO Multi-Thickness Toploader Pack for everyday base cards and standard inserts.
!
