EVORETRO already covered what's guaranteed inside every 2026 Topps Heritage Football hobby box, from base cards to autographs.
This guide focuses on a specific layer of that checklist: the four confirmed insert sets, each pulling from a different angle on NFL history rather than simply repeating the base design with different players.
New Age Performers, All-Pro Series, Through the Years, and The Expansion each carve out their own space in the checklist, distinct from the base set's straightforward 1976 recreation.
Here's what each insert actually delivers, and which one is worth prioritizing depending on what kind of collector you are.
New Age Performers spotlights rising talent across the league, presented in a chromium finish that stands out visually against the traditional card stock used in the rest of the product.
That glossier treatment makes this insert the closest thing in the checklist to a modern Chrome-style chase, giving Heritage a genuine bridge between its vintage identity and current-generation card design.
All-Pro Series draws its inspiration directly from the 1976 Wonder Bread Football set, a 24-card release from the same year Heritage's base design recreates.
This insert's 24-card checklist covers NFL All-Pros from the 2025 season, giving it a genuinely tighter, more curated feel than the much larger base set surrounding it.
Through the Years revisits notable moments from NFL seasons past, pulling storylines from across different years rather than anchoring everything to 1976 specifically.
That broader historical scope gives this insert set genuine appeal to collectors interested in the league's history generally, not just the specific season Heritage's design is built around.
The Expansion insert highlights the NFL's growth to a 28-team lineup in 1976, the same year the Seattle Seahawks and Tampa Bay Buccaneers officially joined the league.
The checklist features one current star per franchise from that expanded lineup, giving the insert a genuinely different structure than a typical player-focused insert set.
New Age Performers is the insert most likely to appeal to collectors chasing modern-feeling chase cards, given its chromium finish and rising-talent focus.
All-Pro Series and The Expansion both lean hardest into the product's 1976 theme, while Through the Years takes the widest historical view of the four.
Collectors building toward a complete Heritage master set should treat All-Pro Series as a priority given its tight 24-card checklist, since it's realistically the fastest insert to complete in full.
Collectors chasing modern star power specifically should prioritize New Age Performers instead, given its focus on current rising talent over historical framing.
Where the base set and Image Variations lean entirely into recreating 1976, these four inserts give Heritage room to layer in both nostalgia and modern relevance without diluting the base design itself.
That balance is part of what separates Heritage from a straightforward reprint exercise, giving the product its own distinct chase structure beyond the vintage aesthetic alone.
Topps had not published official pack odds or print runs for any of the four inserts at the time this checklist was confirmed, which matters more for All-Pro Series and The Expansion given their tighter, more curated card counts.
Waiting for confirmed odds before budgeting toward a specific insert is a safer approach than assuming a smaller checklist automatically means easier pack-to-pack odds.
A base rookie or veteran card from the 400-card checklist is generally the most attainable piece of the product, while these four inserts sit a tier above in scarcity without reaching the exclusivity of the autograph and relic checklist.
That middle position is exactly what makes inserts like these appealing to set builders who want something more distinctive than a base card without needing to chase a signed hit to feel like they landed something meaningful.
Prioritizing insert completion after finishing a base team or player set is a reasonable next step once the more attainable goal is out of the way.
New Age Performers, All-Pro Series, Through the Years, and The Expansion.
All-Pro Series, at 24 cards covering NFL All-Pros from the 2025 season.
The NFL's growth to 28 teams in 1976 with the addition of the Seahawks and Buccaneers.
New Age Performers, thanks to its chromium finish and rising-talent focus.
Four separate insert sets add up fast once you start pulling. Keep them sorted in a EVORETRO 9-Pocket Zip-Up Binder built for a growing collection.
!
