Board game collecting has changed dramatically over the past decade, driven largely by Kickstarter's rise as a platform for deluxe editions, exclusive miniatures, and limited print runs that never reach traditional retail. For someone new to the hobby, it can be genuinely hard to tell the difference between a game worth collecting and one that's just riding crowdfunding hype. Here's a practical starting framework.
The single best piece of advice for a new board game collector is to prioritize games you'll genuinely play over games you're buying purely as a display or investment piece. A collection built around games that see regular table time holds more personal value and is less likely to result in buyer's remorse than one built around chasing whatever's trending on crowdfunding platforms. Once you've identified a few genres or mechanics you enjoy (deck-building, cooperative survival, area control, and so on), that becomes a much more useful filter for future purchases than simply following hype.
Crowdfunded deluxe editions typically add upgraded components (miniatures instead of cardboard tokens, higher-quality card stock, exclusive expansion content) over a game's eventual retail release. Whether that premium is worth paying depends on how much you value the physical presentation versus just wanting to play the game itself; a retail edition of the same core game is often available later at a lower price with the base experience intact, just without the deluxe components. Recent examples, like the Cult of the Lamb board game adaptation that closed its Kickstarter well past 1.8 million GBP, show how much appetite exists for licensed IP deluxe editions specifically.
New collectors often make the mistake of backing every appealing Kickstarter campaign that crosses their feed, which can add up to a real financial commitment before any of the games have even shipped. A more sustainable approach is setting a rough budget for new acquisitions and being selective about which crowdfunding campaigns you back versus which games you wait to buy at retail once reviews and actual gameplay footage are available.
Board games take up considerably more physical space than most other collectible categories, and this is worth planning for before a collection outgrows available shelving. Box dimensions vary enormously across the hobby, from compact card games to sprawling deluxe editions with multiple expansion boxes, which makes uniform shelving harder to plan around than it might first appear. Many experienced collectors recommend measuring available shelf space before making major purchases, particularly for oversized deluxe or Kickstarter editions, since these boxes are frequently larger than their retail counterparts and can quickly overwhelm a shelving setup that wasn't planned with them in mind.
The most common mistake is buying games based purely on component quality or box art without researching actual gameplay mechanics, which can lead to a shelf of beautiful games that rarely get played. The second mistake is neglecting proper card and component sleeving from the start, particularly for games with a heavy card component, since unsleeved cards degrade faster from regular shuffling and handling. The third mistake, specific to crowdfunded games, is underestimating how long fulfillment can take and how variable that timeline often is relative to the campaign's original estimate.
Once your games arrive, proper organization keeps components from getting lost or damaged between sessions. The EVORETRO Plastic Deck Box is a practical way to keep a game's card deck organized and protected, especially for games with a heavy card-driven component. For sorting tokens, resource pieces, and smaller components, the EVORETRO Resealable Team Bags keep everything separated and easy to find during setup. If you're displaying any exclusive miniatures or collector pieces from deluxe editions, the EVORETRO Acrylic Modular Case offers configurable sizing for a growing display.
Is it better to buy a game's retail edition or back its Kickstarter deluxe edition? It depends on how much you value upgraded components versus cost; retail editions are usually cheaper and arrive faster, while deluxe editions offer better production value and exclusive content but come with crowdfunding's inherent shipping delays and risk.
How do I know if a board game is actually good before buying? Checking reviews and gameplay footage from established board game reviewers, rather than relying solely on a campaign's own marketing material, is the most reliable way to gauge quality before committing.
Do board games actually appreciate in value like other collectibles? Some sold-out deluxe editions and limited print runs do see secondary market premiums, but board game collecting is generally driven more by personal enjoyment than investment potential compared to categories like trading cards or graded comics.
Board game collecting rewards a thoughtful, play-first approach more than chasing every crowdfunding campaign that looks appealing. Start with genres and mechanics you know you enjoy, be selective about which deluxe editions are actually worth the premium, and protect your components from the first game night onward. Over time, you'll likely develop a clearer sense of your own collecting priorities, whether that means chasing every deluxe Kickstarter edition in a favorite genre or building a smaller, carefully curated shelf of games you actually bring to the table regularly. Local game stores and dedicated board game cafes are also worth checking out early in your collecting journey, since many host demo nights or rental programs that let you try a game hands-on before committing to a purchase you might not end up enjoying.
For more on tabletop collecting, see our coverage of the Cult of the Lamb board game Kickstarter and our guide to Trading Card Storage Boxes for organizing card-heavy games.
!
