Bowman U Best Football is built around college prospects, not established NFL veterans, which is exactly what makes one specific insert in the 2026 release stand out. Josh Allen and Peyton Manning, two active and retired NFL stars, both appear signing cards in a product otherwise dedicated entirely to players who have not been drafted yet.
The insert is called Best of High School Tribute, and it depicts both quarterbacks the way they looked long before either ever played in the NFL, back in their actual high school uniforms. Autograph Variations of those cards exist for both players.
It is a strange, genuinely unusual fit for a Bowman U Best Football checklist, and that oddity is exactly why the insert has gotten attention well outside the product's usual college-football-focused audience.
Here is what the insert actually shows, how rare the signed versions are, and why this kind of crossover rarely happens in a prospect-driven release like this one.
Bowman U Best Football's entire identity is built on signing players who have not yet reached the NFL, which is what makes finding two established NFL quarterbacks on the autograph checklist so unusual. Neither Allen nor Manning is a current college prospect by any definition.
What connects them to this release instead is the insert's framing device: both are shown as the teenagers they once were, tying their presence to the same high-school-to-college pipeline the rest of the checklist is built around.
The insert set shows NFL players in their actual high school uniforms rather than their current professional ones, creating a visual tribute to where each player's career actually started. It is a design built entirely around nostalgia and origin-story storytelling rather than current performance.
Topps has confirmed Autograph Variations exist for this insert specifically for Josh Allen and Peyton Manning, meaning collectors can chase both a base tribute card and a signed version of the same image. Even the unsigned base version is worth a basic penny sleeve straight out of the pack, since both versions share the same short-print odds.
Allen's tribute card depicts him during his time at Firebaugh High School, long before he became a starting NFL quarterback. The card gives collectors a genuinely rare visual angle on a player most of the hobby only knows from his current NFL career.
His Autograph Variation of the card carries that same high school imagery with a real signature added, making it a meaningfully different collectible than any standard Josh Allen NFL-era autograph already circulating in the hobby.
Manning's version shows him at Isidore Newman School, the same New Orleans high school that has produced multiple NFL quarterbacks across the Manning family and beyond. It is a card that leans directly into football lineage and origin-story appeal.
Like Allen's card, Manning's Autograph Variation pairs that same imagery with a signed copy, giving collectors a genuinely different kind of Peyton Manning autograph than anything tied to his Colts or Broncos career.
Topps has confirmed that every other case of 2026 Bowman U Best Football contains one short-printed Best of High School Tribute insert, which can be either the Allen or Manning card, or a separate Best of Stadiums insert instead. That is a genuinely tight odds structure for a single insert type.
The signed Autograph Variations of those same cards sit even further above that already-scarce base insert, making a confirmed Allen or Manning signature from this specific product a legitimate low-odds chase.
Most crossover autograph inserts that mix NFL veterans into a prospect-focused product lean on nostalgia alone, without an actual new signature behind them. This insert does both, pairing a nostalgic high school image with a genuine new autograph from each player.
That combination, a true signature tied to an origin-story image rather than a current NFL action shot, is rare enough across the hobby that it is worth tracking independent of how either player's current NFL season is going.
They appear in the Best of High School Tribute insert, which depicts NFL veterans in their own high school uniforms.
Yes, confirmed Autograph Variations exist for both the Allen and Manning tribute cards.
Allen's card shows Firebaugh High School, and Manning's shows Isidore Newman School.
Every other case contains one short-printed Best of High School Tribute insert or a Best of Stadiums insert instead.
A card this unusual, two NFL veterans signing a high-school tribute insert inside a college prospect product, is exactly the kind of pull that is worth protecting carefully from the moment it comes out of the pack. Slide it straight into a PSA-ready graded card sleeve if a future submission is even a possibility.
!
