An Enchantress deck lives and dies by how much enchantment support it can pack into 99 cards, and Enchanting Tales happens to be one of the densest single sources of enchantment reprints Magic has ever produced.
Rather than hunting across dozens of different sets for the enchantment staples an Enchantress shell wants, a handful of Wilds of Eldraine boosters can realistically supply a meaningful chunk of the deck.
This is not a coincidence. Enchanting Tales specifically targeted format staples and iconic enchantments, which overlaps heavily with exactly what an Enchantress deck is already looking for.
This guide walks through how to approach building around the sheet's reprints specifically.
Greater Auramancy protects your other enchantments from targeted removal and destruction effects, making it one of the most important pieces of insurance an enchantment-heavy deck can include.
Without protection like this, a dedicated Enchantress deck is vulnerable to a single well-timed removal spell unraveling several turns of setup at once.
Karmic Justice turns an opponent destroying one of your noncreature permanents into a serious tempo setback for them instead, letting you destroy an artifact or enchantment of theirs in return.
This kind of punishment effect discourages opponents from freely removing your key enchantments, buying your deck more time to execute its overall game plan.
Grasp of Fate functions as a powerful Oblivion Ring effect, letting you exile one nonland permanent from each opponent simultaneously, giving an enchantment deck real interaction alongside its value engines.
Because Grasp of Fate is itself an enchantment, it also counts toward any of your deck's enchantment-matters payoffs, doing double duty as both removal and a synergy piece.
Parallel Lives doubles any tokens you would create, while Primal Vigor does the same specifically for +1/+1 counters, and both give an enchantment-focused deck extra payoff if it dips into a secondary tokens or counters theme.
Neither card requires heavy deckbuilding investment to include, making them easy additions to almost any green-inclusive Enchantress shell built around Enchanting Tales reprints.
Rhystic Study and Smothering Tithe both tax your opponents for taking normal actions, generating card and mana advantage respectively whenever they choose not to pay, which most tables will not do consistently.
Both cards fit naturally into an Enchantress deck's identity as enchantments themselves, while also providing the resource advantage needed to keep casting more enchantments each turn.
While Enchanting Tales supplies a strong core, a complete Enchantress deck still needs dedicated payoffs, like cards that draw a card whenever you cast an enchantment, sourced from outside the sheet itself.
Treat Enchanting Tales as your efficient reprint foundation, then layer in dedicated Enchantress payoff cards and a green or white-based manabase to complete the overall shell.
Green-white remains the most traditional Enchantress color pairing, thanks to green's token and ramp support alongside white's removal and protection effects, both of which Enchanting Tales reinforces directly.
A black-inclusive version can lean further into Necropotence-style card advantage, trading some of the token synergy for raw resource generation instead.
Several of the sheet's best Enchantress pieces, including Grasp of Fate and Karmic Justice, remain relatively affordable compared to the format's most expensive staples, making this archetype approachable even on a moderate budget.
Prioritizing Enchanting Tales reprints specifically over harder-to-find older printings of the same cards is often the most cost-effective way to assemble this kind of deck.
Playing a handful of games with your Enchanting Tales-based Enchantress shell before locking in a final list helps reveal whether your protection and interaction suite is actually sufficient against your regular playgroup's removal.
Adjusting the balance between payoff cards and protection pieces based on real games tends to produce a more resilient deck than building entirely from theory.
It protects your other enchantments from targeted removal and destruction.
Yes, it is an enchantment that also functions as removal.
Yes, they support secondary token or counter themes alongside the core enchantment strategy.
It provides a strong foundation, but dedicated payoff cards from outside the sheet still help.
Few single releases have supplied as much genuinely useful Enchantress support as Enchanting Tales did in one bonus sheet. A binder with a secure elastic closure like the EVORETRO 9-pocket binder with elastic keeps your growing enchantment collection organized as you build.
Once your deck is assembled, a sturdy deck box keeps the full 100 cards protected between games. The EVORETRO plastic deck box comfortably fits a full Commander deck.
!
