Eye of Ugin has three meaningfully distinct printings, and unlike many multi-printed cards, all three currently sit in a similar mid-market price range, though one has moved sharply since its release.
Because this card carries genuine name recognition from the Eldrazi Winter ban story, its pricing behaves somewhat differently than a typical reprinted land, with collector demand playing a larger role than usual.
This guide breaks down current, verified pricing across all three printings, checked directly against live market data rather than a single older estimate.
Collectors deciding which copy to buy should weigh both budget and what each specific printing actually represents.
The original Worldwake printing currently sits at roughly 56 to 57 US dollars on the secondary market. As the printing tied directly to the Eldrazi Winter story, it carries genuine historical weight for collectors specifically chasing the original.
Supply from Worldwake is more limited than later reprints, since the set is older and was not designed with the high print runs later reprint-focused sets received.
Modern Masters 2015 reprinted Eye of Ugin specifically to address secondary-market scarcity following its early competitive relevance. Current market pricing sits close to 59 dollars nonfoil, with foil copies running higher, in the low 60s.
This printing is generally the easiest to find in solid condition, since Modern Masters sets were produced specifically to increase supply of in-demand constructed and cube cards.
Eye of Ugin returned in 2026 as part of Reality Fracture's Special Guests insertion line, appearing at a roughly 1-in-55 Play Booster pull rate. Its value at initial spoiler-season release was estimated around 58 dollars.
Current market pricing for this printing has since moved considerably higher, reaching roughly 150 dollars per current mtgstocks data, reflecting both the card's newly renewed profile from the September 2026 Arena ban announcement and genuinely low print supply from its insertion-only distribution.
Two factors converged after release: the card's low, insertion-rate supply relative to a full-set reprint like Modern Masters, and a fresh wave of attention following its September 14, 2026 ban announcement in MTG Arena's Historic and Brawl formats.
That combination pushed the newest printing's price well above its original spoiler-season estimate in a relatively short window, a pattern worth watching for collectors tracking recently reprinted, low-print-run cards.
Players who need a functional copy for Legacy, Vintage, or Commander play get identical performance from any of the three printings, since the card text and function do not change.
Collectors chasing the lowest-cost functional copy should currently look at Worldwake or Modern Masters 2015, both sitting in a similar mid-50s to low-60s range, while the Reality Fracture printing is now the premium option for anyone wanting the newest treatment.
Foil versions across all three printings carry a premium over nonfoil, though the size of that premium varies significantly, with Modern Masters 2015 foils running noticeably higher than nonfoil copies from the same set.
Reality Fracture's Special Guests treatment is a borderless, premium-only presentation, so there is no separate nonfoil-versus-foil split to compare within that specific printing the way there is for the two earlier sets.
Because Reality Fracture is a recent, low-insertion-rate release, its price can move quickly relative to older, full-set reprints, making a same-day price check worthwhile before any purchase rather than relying on a figure from spoiler season.
Cross-checking at least two market sources, such as a live marketplace listing alongside an aggregator's tracked market price, gives a noticeably more reliable current figure than trusting a single cached number.
Worldwake and Modern Masters 2015 currently sit close together in the mid-50s to low-60s dollar range.
Yes, it has risen from an initial roughly 58 dollar estimate to roughly 150 dollars per current market data.
Yes, the card's text and function are unchanged across every printing.
Recent, low-supply printings like Reality Fracture can move in price quickly, so a same-day check is worthwhile.
Yes, renewed ban coverage or anniversary attention can shift demand and pricing quickly.
Worldwake and Modern Masters 2015 are currently the most affordable functional options, sitting close together in price.
Display a high-value pickup in a proper collector album, and protect every copy with sleeves built for long-term storage from the Magic: The Gathering collection.
!
