Gemstone Caverns has quietly become one of the more expensive legendary lands in Magic, and part of that story is how many different printings now exist. The original version came out of the Time Spiral block in 2006, and the card has been getting steadily fancier treatments ever since.
Five real printings exist today, ranging from a plain 2006 rare to a galaxy-foil borderless card released in 2026 that carries a genuinely startling price tag.
This guide walks through each printing, roughly what it costs right now, and which version is worth chasing depending on whether the goal is a playset or a shelf piece.
As always, the rules text is identical across every version. What changes is scarcity, presentation, and price.
Gemstone Caverns first appeared in Time Spiral, card number 274, in the standard black-border frame of the era. As the original printing of a card that has only grown in relevance since, it carries real collector weight on top of its playability.
Current pricing on the original Time Spiral copy sits in the ballpark of $75-80, making it one of the pricier ways to acquire the card despite its age and comparatively plain presentation.
The 2021 Time Spiral Remastered set reprinted the card with the modern frame and updated templating, and this has become the most commonly available version for players who just want a clean copy to play with.
Nonfoil copies currently run somewhere around $57-66, with foil versions considerably higher, often over $100. This is the printing most Legacy and cube players are actually shuffling into their decks today.
Gemstone Caverns has also appeared through The List, seeding into modern booster products at a low pull rate alongside other older, higher-demand cards. Pricing on this version runs close to the Time Spiral original, in the high $60s.
Because it comes from random packs rather than being sold directly, actually finding a specific List copy takes more hunting than simply buying a Time Spiral Remastered single from a seller.
The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Commander decks reprinted the card under the alternate name Glittering Caves of Aglarond, functionally identical to Gemstone Caverns but reflavored into Tolkien's world. The standard version prices around $107.
A surge-foil variant of this same printing runs dramatically higher, and an extremely limited serial-numbered version has sold for figures in the tens of thousands of dollars, firmly in territory reserved for dedicated high-end collectors rather than typical deck builders.
The most recent printing arrives through Edge of Eternities: Stellar Sights, giving the card a borderless treatment alongside a galaxy-foil variant. The standard borderless version prices around $68, close to the Time Spiral Remastered range.
The galaxy-foil variants of this printing are a different story entirely, with some listings running into the hundreds of dollars for a single card, reflecting both the limited nature of Stellar Sights pulls and strong demand for the new art treatment.
Lined up together, playable nonfoil copies span roughly $57 to $110 depending on printing, while the rarest foil and serialized variants climb into territory that has little to do with the card's function at the table. These numbers shift constantly and should be treated as a rough snapshot.
For most players, the gap between the cheapest and most expensive functional printing already represents a meaningful decision, well before factoring in the extreme high-end variants that exist mainly for collectors chasing a specific art treatment.
For a copy that is getting shuffled every game, Time Spiral Remastered nonfoil is the practical choice: widely available, reasonably priced relative to the card's other printings, and instantly recognizable at the table.
For a collection piece, the original Time Spiral rare or one of the newer borderless treatments carry the most story and the most eye-catching presentation, and either deserves a home in a 9-pocket binder with an elastic closure rather than sitting loose in a bulk box.
No, its first printing was Time Spiral in 2006, not Coldsnap.
No, it is the same card under an alternate name and frame from a Lord of the Rings Commander deck.
Time Spiral Remastered nonfoil is the most common and practical choice for a deck that gets shuffled regularly.
No, those variants carry extreme collector premiums that have nothing to do with in-game performance.
A card that spans a $75 original printing and a hundred-thousand-dollar-adjacent modern variant deserves careful handling no matter which version ends up in your collection. A magnetic one-touch holder keeps a display-worthy copy visible and protected without a single unnecessary fingerprint.
!
