Protection from a single color is powerful enough on its own, but Wizards of the Coast has occasionally pushed the ability into far stranger territory. A handful of cards grant protection from everything, protection from a specific chosen player, or protection from an entire category like colored spells.
These are some of the most talked-about cards in Magic's design history, both for how strong they are in play and for how much rules nuance they required to implement cleanly.
This guide walks through the four most extreme protection variants ever printed and explains exactly what each one does and doesn't cover.
Even players who never plan to own these cards benefit from understanding them, since they represent the outer edge of what the protection keyword is capable of.
Progenitus, printed in Conflux, has protection from everything, a variant defined in the Comprehensive Rules as protection from every object regardless of its characteristics. A permanent with this ability can't be targeted, damaged, enchanted, equipped, fortified, or blocked by anything at all.
This makes Progenitus effectively untouchable by any spell or ability that relies on targeting or blocking, though it remains just as vulnerable as any other creature to non-targeted removal such as a board wipe.
True-Name Nemesis, from Commander 2013, grants itself protection from a player chosen when it enters the battlefield. In a two-player game, this made the creature functionally unblockable, undamageable, and completely safe from that opponent's removal for the rest of the game.
This design proved contentious enough in competitive Legacy that the card became one of the most discussed pieces of the format's metagame for years, precisely because "protection from a player" interacts with combat and removal so completely differently than protection from a color.
Emrakul, the Aeons Torn carries protection from colored spells, meaning it can't be targeted, damaged, enchanted, or blocked by any spell with a color, though colorless spells and abilities still interact with it normally.
This distinction is a great example of how protection's "quality" can be defined broadly. Instead of naming one color, this version names an entire category of spells at once, closing off nearly all traditional removal while leaving artifact-based and colorless answers on the table.
Iridescent Angel, from Odyssey, has protection from all colors, which behaves like five separate instances of protection stacked together rather than one combined effect. Mechanically, this means the creature checks each color individually against every incoming spell or ability.
The practical result is nearly identical to Progenitus's protection from everything for most gameplay purposes, though it technically leaves colorless sources as a theoretical answer.
Early attempts to define extreme protection variants forced Wizards of the Coast to formalize concepts like "protection from everything" and "protection from a player" directly in the Comprehensive Rules, since the standard color-based wording didn't cleanly cover them.
Rules 702.16j and 702.16k exist specifically because of cards like Progenitus and True-Name Nemesis, underlining just how far outside the norm these designs actually sit.
Cards this resistant to interaction are prized in Commander precisely because they force opponents to find increasingly narrow answers, such as exile effects, sacrifice demands, or non-targeted removal that ignores protection entirely.
Building around one of these cards means accepting that your opponents will likely pivot toward the handful of answer types that still work, rather than assuming the creature is unbeatable outright.
Cards this resistant to interaction are deliberately kept rare in Magic's overall design, since giving too many creatures this level of protection would meaningfully damage a format's removal-based balance. Each of these four cards represents a specific, carefully considered exception rather than a template Wizards of the Coast reaches for often.
That scarcity is exactly why each one draws so much individual discussion whenever it comes up, rather than blending into a larger, more common category of similarly powerful cards, and why players can usually name all four just from memory alone, something that's rarely true of most other individual keyword rulings in the game.
Yes, since board wipes typically don't target or rely on blocking.
Commander 2013.
No, colorless spells and abilities still apply.
Functionally close, but not identical under the rules.
A card this iconic deserves to be seen, not buried in a box. An EVORETRO Clear Card Display Stand lets you show off a Progenitus or True-Name Nemesis while keeping it fully protected.
For the rest of your extreme-protection collection, the EVORETRO Collector Album keeps everything organized by set and rarity.
!
