Buying just one of the four MTG Star Trek Commander decks is a straightforward decision, but plenty of collectors end up buying two, three, or all four for the exclusive commanders, signed headliners, and LCARS frame cards packed inside.
The problem shows up once the sealed boxes are open: Federation Fleet, Landing Party, Klingon Fury, and We Are the Borg all draw from the same shared pool of generic Commander staples, so the more decks you buy, the more overlapping basic lands and reprint staples pile up.
None of that overlap is a design flaw. Commander precons are built to hit a $74.99 price point using a mix of new exclusive cards and widely reprinted staples that keep production costs down across the whole product line.
This guide walks through what to actually do with the duplicates once you've sorted your decks out, from trading and selling to holding onto a second playset.
Every Commander precon in this release draws on a shared reprint pool for lands, ramp, and generic removal, since Wizards of the Coast reuses the same widely available staples across an entire wave of decks to control per-deck cost.
That means buying two or more of the four $74.99 decks for their exclusive commanders or signed headliners all but guarantees you'll end up holding multiples of the same basic lands and generic interaction spells, not just the odd repeat card.
Before trading, selling, or storing anything, separate what's actually a duplicate generic staple from what's unique to a specific deck's build, since some cards only look interchangeable at a glance.
Keep one full copy of each of the four decks assembled as originally built if you want them playable as-is, then pull every true extra into a separate staples pile you can work through deliberately.
Generic Commander staples are exactly the kind of card local game stores and other Commander players are happy to take in trade, since lands and reprint staples show up in nearly every deck regardless of format.
Because these staples exist outside MTG Star Trek in the broader Commander card pool, they hold trade value well beyond this one product, so a local trade binder is often the fastest way to turn extras into cards you actually need.
Rather than trading everything away, a small pile of extra lands and generic staples is a genuinely useful toolkit for patching other Commander decks you already own, or for building a budget fifth deck out of leftovers from all four precons.
Because ramp, removal, and fixing are largely interchangeable across color-appropriate Commander decks, holding onto a modest stack of extras saves you from buying singles individually the next time you want to upgrade a deck.
If trading locally isn't practical, selling duplicate staples as singles online recoups part of the cost of that second deck purchase, especially when sold in bulk lots rather than one card at a time.
Keep expectations realistic: individual basic lands and common staples typically sell for cents to a couple of dollars each, but a sorted lot of twenty or thirty duplicates can still be worth listing rather than leaving in a box.
If you regularly play with a group, run two pods, or want a spare deck to lend a friend, keeping one duplicate deck fully intact as a second playset avoids having to re-buy it later at a higher secondary market price.
This makes the most sense for whichever deck has proven most popular at your table, whether that's We Are the Borg for its Assimilate mechanic or Federation Fleet for its more straightforward strategy.
Once you've decided what stays, what gets traded, and what gets sold, organize the surviving pile immediately, since loose Commander staples get lost fast once they're mixed back into a box with everything else. A set of EVORETRO 9-Pocket Binder Pages (40 Sheets) keeps sorted staples visible and grouped by color instead of buried in a stack.
Any duplicate that happens to be a foil, a signed headliner, or another chase pull deserves individual protection before it goes anywhere near a trade binder or a sale envelope. A EVORETRO Magnetic One-Touch Card Holders (25-Pack) is worth using on anything valuable before it changes hands.
Not to any meaningful degree; duplicates mainly pile up once you buy more than one copy of the same deck or several decks at once.
Individually they're worth very little, but a stack of them is genuinely convenient for future deck building.
Yes, many players use leftover staples from multiple precons to patch together a budget fifth Commander deck or upgrade an existing one.
Trading is usually faster if you want new cards for your own decks, while selling recoups more cash if you don't need replacements.
Yes, any duplicate signed headliner or foil chase card should be protected individually rather than tossed in with generic staples.
Before you trade, sell, or shelve your duplicate staples, get them sorted with a set of EVORETRO 9-Pocket Binder Pages (40 Sheets) so nothing worthwhile gets lost in the shuffle.
!
