Supernaturals is a 1998 limited series using Marvel characters, produced in partnership with the now-defunct Chaos! Comics as a special Halloween-season release.
The series leaned on a gimmick that is unusual even by 1990s standards: each issue included a cardstock mask insert tied to one of the book's cast of horror-adjacent characters.
Gimmick inserts from this era are hit or miss to confirm online, since a lot of secondary sourcing repeats the same unverified claims without pointing back to an original source.
This guide sticks to what is independently confirmable about Supernaturals: issue count, creative team, the mask-insert gimmick, and how to collect a complete run today.
Supernaturals ran for four issues in 1998, written by Brian Pulido and Marc Andreyko, created through the Chaos! Comics partnership with Marvel for what was pitched as a special Halloween-themed release.
The cast draws on Marvel's horror-adjacent roster, including characters like Ghost Rider, Brother Voodoo, Black Cat, Satana, Gargoyle, and Werewolf by Night across the four-issue run.
Each issue of Supernaturals shipped with a fold-out gatefold cover and a cardstock centerfold mask tied to one of the featured characters, a seasonal gimmick suited to the book's Halloween framing.
This detail is well-documented across back-issue listings and collector marketplaces referencing specific character masks per issue, though a shopper should still confirm an individual listing's insert is intact before buying, since loose inserts are easy to lose over 25-plus years.
Because the mask insert is a physical, separate piece rather than printed directly into the comic, a complete Supernaturals issue is really two components: the comic itself and its matching mask.
Collectors chasing a complete four-issue run should treat the mask as part of the issue's completeness, the same way a collector would treat a trading card insert or a vintage toy's original packaging.
With only four issues and no confirmed annuals or spin-offs, Supernaturals is a short, achievable complete-run project for a 1990s comics collector.
That compact size is part of its appeal: unlike sprawling crossover events from the same era, tracking down all four issues with intact mask inserts is a realistic goal rather than an open-ended chase.
Back-issue bins and online marketplaces regularly list Supernaturals issues specifically noting whether the mask insert is included, which has become the main condition factor buyers check for.
A copy missing its mask insert is still a complete comic story-wise, but collectors building a complete-gimmick run should expect to pay a premium for issues confirmed to still have the original insert attached or enclosed.
The comic and its gatefold cover should be bagged and boarded the same way any standard-size single issue from this era would be, with backer boards sized to prevent the gatefold from creasing.
The separate cardstock mask is best stored alongside its matching issue rather than loose in a box, so the two pieces do not get separated during a future reorganization.
A gatefold cover has an extra fold line that a standard flat cover does not, which makes it more prone to new creases forming if the issue is stored without firm support behind it.
A regular-size comic backer board behind the gatefold keeps that extra fold from deepening every time the issue is pulled out and handled.
The late 1990s saw several publishers lean into horror and Halloween-themed one-off releases, and Supernaturals fits squarely into that broader trend rather than standing as an isolated oddity.
Chaos! Comics was known at the time for horror-leaning original characters, which makes the Marvel partnership an interesting crossover moment between two very different publishers with overlapping genre interests.
Supernaturals was framed from the start as a special seasonal project rather than an ongoing title, which is consistent with why it ran exactly four issues and was never continued or relaunched.
That one-time structure is common for gimmick-driven Halloween releases across the comics industry in this era, where the novelty insert was often the main draw rather than a setup for a longer-running series.
Four issues, all released in 1998.
Back-issue listings and collector marketplaces consistently reference a mask per issue, though buyers should confirm an individual copy still has it.
Brian Pulido and Marc Andreyko, through a Marvel and Chaos! Comics partnership.
No, it is a standalone limited series separate from mainline Marvel stories.
A complete Supernaturals run is worth storing with both the issue and its mask insert protected side by side; start with regular-size comic book bags sized for a standard gatefold issue.
!
